Today, for the second time, I am contemplating the depth of education, of knowledge, that is largely outside of my control. Today’s graduate seminar was held outside under the sun and breeze of the Chapel Hill spring. As the beer loosened our conversation during the third hour of the seminar discussion we left the articles and turned to the possibility of a new course constructed around Cold War and told through movies.
My classmates opined about the lack of knowledge of the undergraduates and how perhaps movies could help alleviate the blank stares that we receive when we talk about the culture and history of the time period. One classmate spoke urgently about the need for the undergraduates to see Dr. Strangelove to have a sense of the reality of Cold War.
As the syllabus was brainstormed this movie and that movie was thrown out, debate sparked about whether or not the book was better. What could inform the undergrads and hope to convey to them that the study of bipolarity is not about theory but about understanding the political worldview of a generation? What could help them understand that school children sat under desks for bomb drills and that people studied these topics not for grades but out of concern for their own survival? I left the class with a list of hastily scrawled titles intending to look them up on Netflix when Charity steps out tonight.
As I walked back to my bike with my slightly inebriated classmate across the North Quad he talked excitedly about movies and the inner life of DC and I felt acutely again the gap between my education and his, or between mine and my professor’s.
My list, scrawled on my paper, grew longer as the rest of the class nodded and agreed or offered alternatives, because I knew none of the titles. It felt as though, as they loosened their tongues, the methodological facade, the analytic skills that graduate school strives to instill in their students, melted away and their deeper educations and knowledge of the world was revealed as the support of their arguments and their passions.
As we walked back to our building my friend raved about how great a class period it was and I thought about the list scrawled on my paper, another list, of three or four necessary books to really be able to understand the topic. Necessary to understanding why it is being discussed and what makes it important. Another set of books I am barely aware of and have never been, nor will ever be, assigned to read.
So again I am thinking about the gap.
When I went to Clemson, I took Milton classes and enjoyed them, but as I studied my professor it was clear that his knowledge was built not on completing of this class in college or that degree but on the education he had been building since he was in grade school, with his Latin and high school classes on social alienation. I remember thinking that if I wanted to be his peer I would have to devote myself and hope to arrive 20 years later.
And I am struck by how similar the feeling is today.